View the Gallery / 9 Photos »

Commemorating the return of West Side Story to Broadway, theater fan Jennifer Lopez got to take on her dream role as Puerto Rican dance sensation Anita.

Posing for a glossy, starlet-studded photoshoot with Vanity Fair, Lopez admits, “I never wanted to be that wimpy Maria, who sits around pining for her guy. I wanted to be Anita, who danced her way to the top.” That’s because it’s almost how J.Lo’s career happened, except with more spray-tan and highlights.

And only Vanity Fair could figure out a way to get together so many young up-and-coming stars to pose together.  Seriously, if you throw a rock, you’re likely to hit a CW or Disney star. See if you can find everybody listed in this gallery. It’s like hunting for Waldo.

Gallery Info: Vanity Fair‘s West Side Story-themed photoshoot featuring Jennifer Lopez, Rodrigo Santoro, Brandon T Jackson, Jay Hernandez, Chris Evans, Cam Gigandet, Drake Bell, Robert Pattinson, Camilla Belle, Ben Barnes, Ashley Tisdale, Minka Kelly, Natalie Martinez, Melanie Diaz, Shane Lynch, Sean Faris, Trilby Glover and Brittany Snow.