After years of silence, Jennifer Lopez is officially done talking about her past relationship drama. The superstar made her stance crystal clear during a recent appearance on Watch What Happens Live, where host Andy Cohen didn’t hold back on asking the question everyone’s been wondering about.
So here’s the tea. Back in early 2021, rumors started swirling that Alex Rodriguez had been messaging Southern Charm reality star Madison LeCroy while he was still engaged to J.Lo. The speculation hit its peak during a heated Southern Charm reunion episode, where LeCroy’s costars accused her of having contact with a “very famous, married ex-MLB player.” Naturally, fans immediately connected the dots to A-Rod.
Now, fast forward to October 15, 2025. Cohen decided to put Jennifer Lopez on the hot seat during his late-night show. He prefaced his question by joking that the “Bravo-verse would kill” him if he didn’t ask about whether those alleged DMs between Alex Rodriguez and Madison LeCroy played a role in the couple’s breakup.
J.Lo took a moment to pause before delivering her response. “You know, I really have nothing to say about my personal life anymore. I feel like I’m done with that,” she said confidently. The live audience immediately erupted in applause, clearly supporting her decision to keep her private life private.
Meanwhile, Madison LeCroy has previously addressed the situation multiple times over the years. She told Page Six back in 2021 that she and Alex had “spoken on the phone” but never met in person, adding that “He’s never physically cheated on his fiancée with me.” However, things got even messier when Madison later claimed that Alex wanted her to be his “side chick,” saying “I told him, I said, ‘If you’re looking for a side chick, which clearly he was, it wasn’t gonna be me.'”
At the time the rumors first emerged, Rodriguez’s representative shot down the allegations completely. His rep told E! News, “I’m not sure who’s looking to benefit from these types of rumors and false stories. They are factually incorrect. Alex is busy concentrating on his businesses and his family.”
Despite all the denials, Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez ended their engagement in April 2021, just weeks after the Madison LeCroy speculation reached its peak. The couple released a joint statement saying they realized they were “better as friends.”
What makes J.Lo’s recent response so powerful is her refusal to rehash old drama. She’s clearly moved on from that chapter of her life and isn’t interested in giving any more energy to speculation about what went down between her ex and the reality TV star. After the audience showed their support, Jennifer smiled and acknowledged them, saying “Yes, support!”
Since the split, both Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez have moved forward with their lives. Meanwhile, Madison LeCroy married firefighter Brett Randle in November 2022 and recently announced she’s expecting her first child.
For anyone hoping J.Lo would spill more details about the situation, her message is loud and clear: she’s done discussing her personal relationships in the public eye. Sometimes the classiest response is no response at all, and Jennifer Lopez just proved exactly that.
