Andrew Rannells Claims Kevin Spacey Asked Him on a Date After Joel Schumacher’s Blunt Backstage Warning

5 Min Read
Andrew Rannells and Kevin Spacey
Credit: Steven Bergman/AFF-USA.COM / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com & Spread Pictures / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com

Highlights

  • Andrew Rannells revealed on a podcast that Kevin Spacey rubbed his neck backstage at The Book of Mormon.
  • Late director Joel Schumacher, who was in the dressing room, immediately warned Rannells to stay away from Spacey.
  • Spacey sent a handwritten letter asking Rannells on a date about a week later, but the actor never responded.

never publicly shared his backstage encounter with until this week. Speaking on The Downside With Gianmarco Soresi podcast, the two-time Tony nominee detailed an uncomfortable dressing room visit during his 2011–2012 Broadway run in The Book of Mormon.

“I’ve never told this story before. He asked me on a date once,” Rannells said. “He sent me a letter to The Book of Mormon. Handwritten.”

The letter arrived roughly a week after Spacey attended a performance and made his way backstage. At the time, Rannells was earning widespread acclaim and a Tony nomination for his breakout turn as Elder Price. Celebrity guests routinely stopped by after the curtain fell, often without warning.

“There were always a lot of really fun people there, but sometimes they would bring them up into our dressing rooms, but with no notice,” Rannells explained. “So after the show, we’re getting changed. There’s a knock on my door.”

Andrew Rannells braves the rain outside the Today Show this morning in New York City
Andrew Rannells braves the rain outside the Today Show this morning in New York City on June 10, 2025 Pictured: Andrew Rannells braves the rain outside the Today Show this morning in New York City. Credit: Eric Kowalsky / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com sales@mega.global

Three major Hollywood figures stood outside. “It was Goldie Hawn, Kevin Spacey, and ,” Rannells recalled. “They were not together, but they all walked up together. So then we were all crammed in my dressing room.”

Inside the tight space, Spacey initiated physical contact. “Kevin Spacey was sort of, like, rubbing my neck a little bit as we were standing there,” Rannells said.

Schumacher, the late filmmaker who had directed Spacey in the 1996 legal drama A Time to Kill, intervened immediately. “And Joel Schumacher, who was very close to me, said, ‘Stay away from that man. Stay away from that man,'” Rannells recounted.

Spacey stood close enough to hear the blunt warning. According to Rannells, the American Beauty actor pushed back defensively. “And Kevin was like, ‘Hey, come on, come on,'” Rannells said.

Kevin Spacey On The Red Carpet In Venice, Italy
Kevin Spacey attends the red carpet at the 2025 Venice International Film Festival on August 31, 2025, in Venezia, Italy. Photo credit: ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com sales@mega.global

Despite Schumacher’s direct intervention, Spacey followed up days later. “And then like a week later, I got a handwritten letter from him asking me on a date, and I just never responded,” Rannells stated.

Rannells offered the memory without embellishment, letting the sequence of events speak for itself. His account highlights how whispered warnings and protective interventions often circulated informally among industry peers years before public reckonings took hold.

Spacey, a two-time Academy Award winner for The Usual Suspects and American Beauty, later faced numerous civil and criminal cases involving misconduct allegations. None of those legal proceedings resulted in a criminal conviction or civil liability. Spacey has consistently denied all allegations of wrongdoing and has not been found guilty of any crime.

Andrew Rannells and Tuc Watkins at Hulu's “Paradise” season 2 premiere
Andrew Rannells and Tuc Watkins at Hulu’s “Paradise” season 2 premiere held at the Paramount Theatre on February 18, 2026 in Los Angeles, CA. Credit: Starbuck/ AFF-USA.COM / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com sales@mega.global

Since those trials concluded, Spacey has worked to rebuild his career internationally, recently directing and starring in Holiguards Saga — The Portal of Force and appearing in the Spanish drama Torrente for President. Representatives for Spacey have been contacted for comment regarding Rannells’s remarks.

For Rannells, the brief interaction ended the moment he chose to leave Spacey’s handwritten note unanswered. He credited his close friend’s candid, in-the-moment warning with making the boundary unmistakably clear.

Around the Web