Shannon Elizabeth Earns Over $1.2 Million in First Week on OnlyFans — And Most of It Came From DMs

The American Pie star proves that nostalgia, savvy, and a paywall are a powerful combination.

6 Min Read
Shannon Elizabeth
Credit: RobinLori/INSTARimages.com

Highlights

  • Shannon Elizabeth earned $1.2M+ in her first week on OnlyFans, launched April 16
  • Over half of earnings came from direct fan messages, not subscription fees
  • Elizabeth plans to donate a portion of profits to her Shannon Elizabeth Foundation

Move over, Hollywood. Shannon Elizabeth has found a better deal — and it doesn’t require a studio greenlight.

The American Pie actress, who turned heads and broke the internet long before breaking the internet was a thing, has reportedly crossed the $1.2 million mark in her very first week on OnlyFans. That’s not a typo. Seven figures. Seven days. No co-stars required.

Creators Inc. CEO Andy Bachman confirmed that Elizabeth “grossed seven figures in her first week on the platform,” with sources telling Variety that she surpassed the $1.2 million mark in her first seven days on the subscription platform, which officially launched on Thursday, April 16.

Shannon Elizabeth
Shannon Elizabeth at the MTV Movie Awards, 6/5/2001, by Robert Hepler.” Credit: everett225/depositphotos.com

For a woman who made her name in a 1999 comedy about a teenage boy with a pie, the pivot to OnlyFans feels almost poetically full-circle.

A source close to the star told Page Six that Elizabeth “has officially made over seven figures” on the platform, with the insider adding that “over half of that was earned through direct messages to OnlyFans users, while tips and posts accounted for the rest.”

So what’s driving the demand? Apparently, access. Despite the platform’s reputation, Elizabeth’s content reportedly does not include full nudity. Instead, the appeal seems to be rooted in something more personal and direct: access.

Shannon Elizabeth
Shannon Elizabeth at arrivals for Entertainment Weekly THE MUST LIST Party, Deep, New York, NY, June 16, 2005. Photo by: Gregorio Binuya/Everett Collection. Credit: everett225/depositphotos.com

Elizabeth has been vocal about exactly why she made the leap. “I’ve spent my entire career working in Hollywood, where other people controlled the narrative and the outcome of my career. This new chapter is about changing that, showing off a more sexy side no one has seen, and being closer to my fans,” she said earlier this month.

“OnlyFans gives me the opportunity to offer something more — a behind the scenes, unfiltered look at my life and a genuine connection that no other platform allows,” she added in a statement. “This isn’t just content to watch from a distance. This is for the people who have always shown up for me, and I want them to feel that.”

Her manager is equally enthusiastic. Bachman celebrated the career move in a statement to Variety, saying: “Shannon has always been someone who genuinely enjoys connecting with and giving back to her fans, and this allows her to do that in a more direct, meaningful way than ever before. It’s a powerful model, and right now, there’s nothing more effective at facilitating that connection than OnlyFans.”

Shannon Elizabeth
MARCH 19, 2012: Shannon Elizabeth at the Los Angeles Premiere of “American Reunion” held at the Grauman’s Chinese Theater. Credit: PopularImages/depositphotos.com

As for what her rep had to say about the jaw-dropping earnings? Classic Hollywood diplomacy. “It is not my place to discuss my client’s finances, so I can’t be specific,” they told Us Weekly on April 27. “But Shannon has done very well.”

That may be the understatement of the year.

The description on Elizabeth’s OnlyFans account reads: “Here you’ll find the side of me that doesn’t make it into movies — more playful, spontaneous, and completely unscripted. If you’ve ever been curious what I’m really like… You’re about to find out.”

The timing of the launch wasn’t without personal complexity. Elizabeth revealed she was going onto OnlyFans just one day after filing for divorce from Simon Borchert after five years of marriage. But rather than retreat, the 52-year-old leaned in — hard.

Shannon Elizabeth
Shannon Elizabeth attends the New York premiere of ‘The Private Lives of Pippa Lee’ at the AMC 19th in New York City on November 16, 2009. Credit: Roger Wong/INFphoto.com

She joins a growing list of high-profile creators on the platform that includes Carmen Electra, Bhad Bhabie, Mia Khalifa, The Sopranos star Drea de Matteo, and Sophie Rain.

The money isn’t just going into her pocket, either. Elizabeth’s representative told Page Six that the star intends to dedicate some of her OnlyFans earnings to her charity, the Shannon Elizabeth Foundation, and plans to hold a gala in Las Vegas, Nevada, sometime in the summer.

“She’s always hustling and genuinely loves interacting with her fans,” her rep told Page Six.

Week one is in the books. The question now is whether the momentum holds — or whether, like so many subscription models, the novelty curve catches up. Either way, Shannon Elizabeth has already made her point loudly and profitably: she doesn’t need Hollywood anymore. Hollywood might need her.


  • Rihanna Debuts Her Baby Girl Rocki on the Cover of W Magazine [Celebitchy]
  • Laverne Cox Deployed Some Drama [Go Fug Yourself]
  • Parker Posey Gets In on 'The Traitors' Action With 'The Mob' for Hulu [Pajiba]
  • Vinnie Hacker, the 23-Year-Old Michelangelo of Thirst Traps, Plots a Life After Influencing [Kenneth in the 212]
  • Sounds Like Teen Spirit: A Review of 'Screams from the Tower' [Boy Culture]